Raw, Vegan or Classic: Dog Food Decoded

Picking the right dog food is not just about keeping your dog healthy—it’s about boosting its happiness and overall quality of life. Various choices, from raw and vegan to traditional commercial diets, can make determining the best option overwhelming.  

Whether you’ve had dogs for years or are new to pet parenting, understanding these dog food options can help ensure you’re giving your pup the best nutrition possible. 

The Raw Diet

The raw diet for dogs, often called the BARF diet (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food), replicates the ancestral diet of dogs with a mix of raw meat, bones, organ meats, fruits and vegetables.

This natural approach to feeding is gaining traction among pet owners; a global survey found that two-thirds of dogs (66%) are fed raw animal foods. Advocates of the raw diet tout numerous benefits, such as enhanced digestion, smaller and less odorous stools, increased energy, shinier coats, healthier skin and cleaner teeth. 

However, there are some considerations you need to think about before starting your dog on a raw diet. Key concerns include potential nutritional imbalances and the risk of bacterial contamination, such as Salmonella and E. coli

Tips for Safely Preparing and Handling Raw Dog Food

If you’re thinking about switching your dog to a raw diet, there are several steps you can take to minimize risks and protect your dog’s health.

  • Source responsibly. Always use high-quality, fresh ingredients from reputable sources to minimize the risk of contamination.
  • Try commercially prepared raw food. If you’re unsure about switching your pet to a fully raw diet, consider starting with freeze dried raw dog food. Commercially prepared with human-grade ingredients, these recipes reduce the risk of contamination while still providing the benefits of raw feeding.
  • Keep it clean. Maintain strict hygiene practices, washing hands, utensils and surfaces before and after preparing raw food.
  • Store Safely. Raw dog food should be stored in the freezer and thawed in the refrigerator to prevent bacterial growth.
  • Monitor your dog. Monitor your dog’s health and overall condition. Consult your veterinarian if you observe any concerning changes, such as significant weight loss, vomiting or diarrhea.

The Vegan Diet

Interest in plant-based diets for pets is on the rise, with 10.4% of pet owners intermittently feeding their dogs a plant-based diet. A vegan diet for dogs eliminates all animal products, focusing on a mix of grains, legumes, vegetables and fruits, supplemented with essential nutrients like vitamin B12, taurine and L-carnitine to maintain nutritional balance.

A vegan dog diet can provide several health advantages, such as alleviating allergies, aiding in weight management and enhancing digestion.

Although dogs are omnivores and can survive on a plant-based diet, thriving on such a regimen requires careful planning. The challenge is ensuring the diet meets your pet’s nutritional requirements, particularly for protein, essential fatty acids and specific vitamins and minerals generally abundant in animal-based products. 

Tips for Balancing a Vegan Dog Diet

Follow these tips to safely transition your pup to a vegan diet, ensuring they receive the necessary macro- and micronutrients for a happy and active life.

  • Consult a veterinarian. Before transitioning your dog to a vegan diet, consult a veterinarian or a pet nutritionist to help formulate a balanced diet plan.
  • Choose complete formulas. Select commercially available vegan dog foods labeled complete and balanced to meet nutritional standards.
  • Supplement wisely. Incorporate essential nutrients often lacking in vegan diets, such as taurine, L-carnitine and vitamins B12, D and E.
  • Monitor health regularly. Schedule regular veterinary check-ups to assess your dog’s health and adjust the diet as necessary.

The Classic Diet

The traditional commercial diet for dogs typically comes in two forms: dry kibble and wet canned food. These products are designed to meet the nutritional needs of dogs at every life stage, from puppies to seniors, offering a balanced diet tailored to their specific requirements. Pre-packaged for convenience, these foods are easy to store and ready to serve, making mealtimes simpler for busy pet owners.

Commercial dog foods are formulated with the expertise of veterinarians and pet nutritionists to ensure nutritional completeness. They are regulated by industry standards set by bodies like The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO), ensuring they contain the proper balance of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals.

Despite these benefits, there are concerns about commercial dog foods, particularly regarding additives and preservatives used to enhance flavor and extend shelf life. While many additives are safe, some, like ethoxyquin and sulfites, could pose long-term health risks. Additionally, the quality of protein sources can vary; some brands may use less desirable meat sources and fillers like corn, wheat and soy, which offer limited nutritional value and might not be easily digestible for all dogs.

How to Choose High-Quality Commercial Dog Food

You can help your dog get the best nutrition possible by choosing high-quality, human-grade, ethically sourced pet food. Use the following tips to find the right food for your furry friend. 

  • Check the ingredients. Prioritize foods where high-quality proteins, such as chicken, beef or fish, are listed as the first ingredients.
  • Understand the labels. Look for products marked as “complete and balanced,” which indicates they meet the nutritional standards set by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles.
  • Avoid unnecessary additives. Select brands that minimize artificial flavors, colors and preservatives, opting for natural preservatives like vitamin C (ascorbic acid) or vitamin E (mixed tocopherols).
  • Opt for human-grade ingredients. Pet foods made with human-grade ingredients, such as wild-caught salmon dog food, include proteins, vegetables, fruits and grains that are fit for human consumption. This indicates that they are superior to the ingredients typically found in commercial pet foods, offering better nutrition for your dog.

Make the Right Choice for Your Pet’s Health

Exploring all the different dog food options can seem overwhelming, but understanding the choices available can help you pick the right one for your pet. Whether looking at raw, vegan or traditional commercial diets, the most important thing is to think about what best suits your dog’s health and needs. 

A carefully chosen diet can affect your dog’s well-being and energy levels. Take your time to choose well and don’t hesitate to discuss it with your vet to ensure your dog thrives on its new diet.

Photo of author

Alfie Jack

Alfie Jack, a Pet Care and Animal Behavior Expert with a Doctor of Veterinary Medicine, specializes in veterinary health, animal behavior, and pet nutrition. His veterinary experience and compassionate approach to animal care provide valuable insights for pet owners seeking to maintain the health and happiness of their pets.
Share on:

Leave a Comment